Without water, health workers face an impossible task

on
16 May 2019

In a world-first, the number of healthcare facilities globally with a sufficient standard of water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) to keep both health workers and patients healthy has been measured, exposing a worldwide healthcare crisis.

Danielle Zielinski, our Health and WASH Officer at WaterAid America explains the situation and how we will use next week’s World Health Assembly to encourage health ministers to take the next step to ensure this issue is prioritised and addressed. 

Imagine you work 12-hour days in a high-stress environment. There’s no decent toilet. No soap to wash your hands. Thirsty? Sorry, you’ll have to leave and walk to the nearest water source.

Many of us would refuse to work under such conditions. But this is the everyday reality for far too many health workers in low- and middle-income countries.

New data a step forward

In April, the WHO-UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme released the first-ever global estimates for water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) in healthcare facilities. They found that one in four healthcare facilities globally do not have clean water on site, one in five have no sanitation services, and one in six have no handwashing facilities. 

The numbers get even worse if you look specifically at health facilities in less-developed countries: 45% of healthcare facilities in the least developed countries have no clean water on site. In sub-Saharan Africa, only 23% of facilities have decent toilets.

While the report is a major step forward in measuring progress, it also shows there’s a lot we don’t know about tracking WASH in healthcare facilities. 

Further evidence needed 

Few countries are collecting even basic data on this topic, making it hard for governments to effectively address the crisis. For example, only 18 countries had sufficient data to estimate coverage of decent toilets, and only four countries had data on how health facilities are cleaned.

We need better data to compel governments to improve conditions that health workers face day after day at work.  Places like Yiraber Health Centre in rural Ethiopia, where staff have to choose daily which rooms to mop because they don’t have enough water to clean them all. Here, nurses reuse water for patients and cannot wash their hands as often as they like.

Yaye Wale, 25, a clinical nurse, standing beside buckets of water used for washing medical equipment in the Delivery Room at Yiraber Health Centre, Jabi Tehnan, West Gojjam, Ethiopia, December 2018.
WaterAid/ Genaye Eshetu
Yaye Wale, 25, a clinical nurse, standing beside buckets of water used for washing medical equipment in the Delivery Room at Yiraber Health Centre, Jabi Tehnan, West Gojjam, Ethiopia, December 2018.

“It is hard to express it – it is a sorrowful experience working here,” says Yaye Wale, a clinical nurse at the health centre. “I feel sad that, instead of healing patients, I might expose them to other diseases. Though we work in health, we are in a highly infectious environment.”

Life-threatening for staff and patients

Lack of water, sanitation and hygiene in health facilities is risky both for health workers and their patients. Unhygienic conditions contributed to more than 800 health workers contracting Ebola during the 2014-2016 West Africa epidemic, resulting in more than 500 health worker deaths. Similarly, in the current outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo, significant numbers of new cases are being acquired within healthcare settings. 

Overall, 15% of patients in developing countries acquire at least one infection during a hospital stay, and healthcare associated infections continue to be major drivers of antibiotic resistance. In addition to the implications for disease transmission, unhygienic conditions in healthcare facilities negatively impact health worker attendance, morale, retention and safety.

Yaye Wale, 25, a clinical nurse, standing with a cup of water and Oral Rehydration Therapy (ORS) he uses to demonstrate for parents whose children have diarrhoea, Yiraber Health Centre, Jabi Tehnan, West Gojjam, Ethiopia, December 2018.
WaterAid/ Genaye Eshetu
Yaye Wale, standing with a cup of water and Oral Rehydration Therapy he uses to demonstrate to parents whose children have diarrhoea.

"A year back, I was hired here with two of my friends. But they couldn't handle it,” Wale said. “They said, 'How can we work on children's health without water in the health centre?' and they left soon after.”

What are we doing to solve this issue?

The good news is that this is a solvable problem – as WaterAid’s work in multiple countries shows. Alongside the new data, the World Health Organization (WHO) and UNICEF have published a report on Practical Steps to Achieve Universal Access to Quality Care that captures experiences from around the world and suggests actions that governments and other stakeholders can take to address this pressing issue. These include investing in training the health workforce, establishing national standards for WASH in healthcare facilities, improving data collection and monitoring, and strengthening accountability.

Next week, at the World Health Assembly, we have the opportunity to take the next step in ensuring WASH in healthcare facilities is prioritised and addressed. A proposed resolution on the topic –  spearheaded by the governments of Zambia and Tanzania – will be on the table. 

To date, 170 civil society organisations and individuals have signed a letter of support urging member states to adopt the resolution and make a public commitment to improving these critical services in all healthcare facilities.

This issue affects everyone—patients and health workers alike. But the need for WASH goes beyond infection prevention and control. It’s also about dignity. It’s about pride. It’s about giving frontline health workers the basic resources they need to do their jobs.